Cottingham's crime rate in May 2023 stood at 4.9 per 1,000 residents, placing it 38.7% below the UK average of 8.0 per 1,000. For a population of 13,110, this translates to 64 total crimes recorded—a figure that equates to one reported incident for every 205 residents over the course of the month. The most prevalent crime type was violence and sexual offences, accounting for 29.7% of all incidents, followed by public order offences (20.3%) and shoplifting (10.9%). These figures suggest a mixed picture of local crime dynamics, with violent crime remaining a significant concern despite the overall decline compared to the UK average. The seasonal context of May—characterised by longer evenings, bank holidays, and increased outdoor socialising—may partly explain the prevalence of public order offences, as well as the relatively low rate of burglary. However, the sharp rise in bicycle theft (up 400% from the previous month) and the doubling of other crime categories, such as possession of weapons, indicate areas requiring targeted attention. Cottingham’s violent crime rate (1.5 per 1,000) is 46% below the UK average, which may reflect the area’s smaller, more tightly knit community structure. Conversely, public order offences exceed the UK average by 52%, a discrepancy that could be linked to localised factors such as the presence of recreational or commercial hubs. The data also highlights a significant gap between Cottingham and the UK average for anti-social behaviour, which is 70% below the national rate, underscoring the effectiveness of community engagement or policing strategies in this built-up area.