New Mills' crime rate in October 2023 stood at 5.7 per 1,000 residents, a figure that places the area 28.7% below the UK average of 8.0 per 1,000. This relatively low rate is consistent with the area's character as a smaller built-up area within High Peak, where crime trends often reflect local dynamics rather than national patterns. The most common crime types were violence and sexual offences (38.3% of total crimes), followed by criminal damage and arson (23.4%) and anti-social behaviour (10.6%). These figures highlight a balance between interpersonal crimes and property-related incidents, though the latter category's composition differs significantly from the UK average. For instance, criminal damage and arson in New Mills are 106% above the UK average, while anti-social behaviour is 53% below. This divergence may be partly explained by the area's seasonal context: October brings shorter days and the Halloween period, factors that could contribute to increased vandalism or public order issues. The overall crime rate, while showing a 47% increase from September, remains in line with the area's historical trend of lower-than-average crime levels, suggesting that local factors such as community cohesion or environmental features may play a role in sustaining this profile.