York’s crime rate in January 2024 stood at 6.8 per 1,000 residents, placing it 8.1% below the UK average of 7.4. This performance reflects a combination of local factors and seasonal dynamics. Violence and sexual offences accounted for 37.1% of all reported crimes, making them the most prevalent category. This is 4% below the UK average, a trend likely influenced by York’s historic character and lower population density compared to major cities. Anti-social behaviour followed closely, contributing 18.5% of incidents but remaining 31% above the national average—a discrepancy that may be linked to the city’s compact urban environment and the concentration of social hubs in its medieval core. Shoplifting, at 12.5% of total crimes, was 58% higher than the UK average, a figure that could be partially explained by York’s status as a tourist destination, where historic shopping areas attract both visitors and potential offenders. The seasonal context of January—a post-holiday period with reduced retail footfall and shorter daylight hours—likely contributed to a lower volume of outdoor crimes compared to other months. However, the persistence of high anti-social behaviour rates suggests that community engagement and policing strategies in residential and nightlife areas require continued focus. York’s performance highlights a nuanced interplay between its unique geographic and demographic profile and broader national crime trends.