East Horsley's crime rate in May 2024 stood at 3.1 per 1,000 residents, placing it 63.1% below the UK average of 8.4 per 1,000. This stark contrast underscores the area's generally low crime profile, a characteristic consistent with its semi-rural setting within the larger Guildford borough. The most common offences were violence and sexual offences (6 cases, 33.3% of total), followed by anti-social behaviour (5 cases, 27.8%) and public order offences (3 cases, 16.7%). These figures align with the area's likely mix of residential properties and limited commercial activity, which may reduce opportunities for more complex crimes. Seasonal factors, including longer evenings and the start of the summer social season, may have contributed to the rise in anti-social behaviour and public order offences. However, the area's low population density and the presence of green spaces could also explain the relatively low rates of property crime. The UK comparison highlights East Horsley's position as a safer-than-average location, though the small number of incidents means fluctuations can appear more pronounced. Bicycle theft—though only one incident—exceeded the UK average by 150%, a figure that may reflect a temporary increase in cycling activity, such as during a local event or due to warmer weather.